« The Panama Canal | Main | 'I Don't Count: A Minority Report on the French Riots »
November 9, 2005
Let's Stop Bird Flu
By: Rowan Wolf
Call me silly, but despite some claims that the Avian Flu is hype for profit, I think there really is a threat. New cases among birds keep springing up, and another person has died in Vietnam. However, the current approach to "controlling" and preparing seems very wrong-headed to me. Right now, the Avain Flu is just taht - avian - for the most part. The more domestic birds who are infected, the more likely it is to make its mutation to humans. So let's address that issue. Stop it in birds.
I see the Avain Flu as having some similarilites to CJD - "Mad Cow" disease. Mad Cow is reportedly caused by the feeding and processing procedures with cattle. The way that Mad Cow is controlled is by ending the practice of feeding cows to other cows.
The Avain Flu is a different disease all together, but it strikes the domestic poultry "factories." The birds, all over the world are kept in absolutely unbelievable conditions. Tightly packed, sometimes with beaks cut off so they won't damage each other. The droppings from the birds are used for fertilizer, but also for fish food in some places. Who knows what other food that birds and their droppings may end up in.
Millions of flocks have been "culled" by now. That has to be a very expensive proposition. Would changing the conditions that these birds are kept in be more expensive? Would vaccinating them be more expensive? I would think that it would probably be much less expensive than a human pandemic.
The International Monetary Fund estimates that an Avian Flu pandemic would cost $800 billion. Now that is a lot of money. Reportedly there is a bird flu vaccine - for birds. One does not exist for humans and the disease could sweep the planet for years before it came under some form of control. At an economic cost of almost a trillion dollars, changing the conditions in which domestic poultry are kept and raised, and vaccinating the flocks against the virus, would seem to be cheap by comparison.
I propose that if the governments of the world are truly concerned about the possibility of an Avian Flu pandemic, that putting the money into bird vaccinations and improving conditions would be much more effective that the current strategy. A strategy, I might add, which seems to be totally ineffective and very expensive.
Posted by Rowan at November 9, 2005 5:41 AM Category: Environment
Comments
One person I was talking to on this issue tells that the big concern is a mutation. If the Avian flu virus infects a person who already has a human flu virus, the virus could mutate so that it is transmittable between humans without the birds.
Her suggestion was to carry antiseptic for our hands in our pockets, particularly when we go grocery shopping and handle the carts. Her suggestion is that this is one major way that viruses like this are passed to humans.
I'm not sure, but it is something to think about.
Posted by: Shawna at November 10, 2005 2:33 PM